Go Back to:
Imports Summary | Other Archives |
Current Forecast
September 21, 1998
Crude Oil and the World's Cash Flow Problem
Missing 81 Billion Dollars
From the "oil-patch" perspective,
the current world financial problems can be related, in part,
to the fall in the price of oil - a catalyst, or as we say in the U.S. "the straw that broke the camel's
back." Over the past 9 months, industrialized countries collectively saved an estimated
81 billion dollars. That's 81 billion dollars that did not flow to producing countries and oil
companies. No doubt many emerging nations that find themselves in financial trouble
this year were extended credit based on their forecasts for crude oil production and sales. No one
anticipated that a mere 3% increase in the world's crude oil production would result in
a 32% reduction in world-wide cash flow.
Oil is Not Gold
Relying on oil to secure credit
doesn't work as well as gold (or other solid, tangible items). Think of the problem in terms of storage. An ounce of gold is
worth roughly $290.00. An ounce of gold is tiny and anyone can purchase it. You could put many ounces -- even
pounds of gold in a small safe. When a lender calls a debt due, he can take possession of the gold.
On the other hand, the equivalent of one ounce of gold in oil at $12/barrel is
24 barrels. At 42 gallons per
barrel, that would be 1,008 gallons of crude oil.
Try storing 1,008 gallons of crude oil in a safe. . .
Logistically, the best way to store huge amounts
of crude oil is to leave it in the ground where we refer to it as "reserves." The problem is
that as long as the oil is in the ground, no one knows exactly how much of it there is.
Petroleum Engineers around the world spend long hours diligently calculating and
recalculating reserves. Because reserves are still in the ground, the value of the
reserves is based on the cost of production, i.e. if you cannot produce the oil for the market
value or better, then you theoretically don't have any reserves. Thus, reserves are generally
calculated as "that oil which can be produced at the current market value of crude oil." You
should know this tidbit because if the price of crude oil remains low past January 1, 1999, next
year's estimate of reserves will be significantly lower than this year's estimate. Not that there
is any less oil in the world -- it's just not available at the current price.
See the table of data by Country
Production swelled on all fronts in 1997. The following pictures show crude oil production by
OPEC and NON-OPEC countries. The units are in Thousands of Barrels of Production per Day (BOPD).
Once oil is produced
it is quantifiable. It is also a nightmare to handle. Ideally, you produce it,
put it on a tanker, and deliver it to a refinery where it is refined into products which are sold
and almost immediately consumed. The system is very delicately balanced. While there are a few
facilities around the world that store
crude oil (wide spots in the transportation system), there is no storage space to allow accumulation
of oil over time. When the system gets out of balance as it did this year, low demand coupled with
high production results in excess oil with no place to go. The result is chaos -- and low crude
oil prices. This situation would never happen with
gold. While gold "reserves" surely depend on production costs, once gold is produced it
can be stored and saved to control the market value. Gold also does not disappear, whereas oil is a
once-through product. Once it is refined and sold, it is consumed and gone. Although
gold is used in some manufacturing, it can also be
recycled -- traded over and over again, so it has lasting, and accumulating, value to the world.
So, although oil has often been referred to as Black Gold, it has some significant limitations that
should be considered as the world deals with rapid industrialization in emerging economies. Remember,
the U.S. economy, which works
so well now, was originally developed on a gold standard, not oil.
Getting Better
If production is on the path projected, the world should be nearing balance -- although additional
factors must now be considered. For instance, as a result of the lack of cash flow and
subsequent credit problems, economies slowed down and demand for oil decreased in many countries,
therefore production actually must be reduced to levels below former production rates to
balance supply with demand. Once economies become reestablished, demand should rise, and so
should the price of crude oil. Right now, it looks like the world economy is on the path to
recovery. Success depends on how well disciplined producers will be in managing crude oil
production.
The NOESIS forecast shows recovery of crude oil prices in 1999, assuming producing nations continue
to hold crude oil production down. By next year, the U.S. will be in a normal buying mode, which
will increase bidding for crude oil available on the open market and will further tighten the
supply.
Winners and Losers
The losses associated with the drastic crude oil price reduction are not shared equally. Countries that
depend largely on income from the sale of exported crude oil and companies which only produce oil, or
support production, are taking the biggest hits. Economics of
Crude Oil Prices.
Countries
that produce no oil, but consume oil, have been blessed with huge savings this past year. Major, fully
integrated oil companies have seen losses in crude oil production, but savings at the refinery in
their purchase price of crude oil. In some cases, product prices have not completely followed the
price of crude oil downward, so there remains some profit on the sale of products.
Above all, U.S. consumers and the U.S. economy has benefited enormously from the price decrease.
As consumers of 26% of the world's resources, collectively, we saved 21 billion dollars in the
past 9 months.
On the other hand, those institutions that invested heavily in foreign economies that were
largely depending on cash flow
from crude oil are now seeing losses. Some countries that depended on revenues or income from
those investments are failing. The situation is
complex -- better left to the world's economists to sort out. But there's no question that
over-production of crude oil in the winter of 1997-1998 played a key role in producing
the world's economic problems.
REGIONAL FORECASTS
U.S. crude oil inventories decreased by 2.4 million barrels from 328.1 to
325.7 million barrels. The decrease occurred largely due to low level of purchases of imported
crude oil. Input to refineries increased an insignificant amount from 15.520 to 15.560 million
bpd (98.9 % capacity). Prices of gasoline remained unseasonably low, while refiners managed to edge
diesel prices slightly higher.
The short term gasoline price forecast
reflects the anticipated shortage of gasoline due to likely logistics problems in U.S.
refineries this fall as refiners deal with burgeoning inventories of distillate (heating oil). West
Coast prices are predicted to increase in concert with East Coast prices and crude oil prices.
Forecast Graphs
EIA U.S. Refining Data
| Input/Output | Million BPD | Imports | Million BPD | Inventory | Million BBL |
Week | Sep 4 | Sep 11 | Sep 4 | Sep 11 | Sept 4 | Sep 11 |
Crude Oil | 15.520 | 15.560 | 8.487 | 8.631 | 338.1 | 325.7 |
Gasoline | 8.237 | 8.193 | 0.524 | 0.460 | 207 | 205.7 |
Distillate | 3.476 | 3.669 | 0.181 | 0.173 | 144.7 | 148.7 |
Resid | 0.694 | 0.751 | 0.325 | 0.291 | 39.0 | 39.0 |
World crude oil prices reported by EIA
as of September 11: Arabian Lt (34 API) - $12.55, Nigerian Bonny Light
(37 API) $12.80, UK Brent (38 API) $12.82, and Mexico Maya
(22 API)- $8.92.
Posted prices for crude oil as of Sept 20, 1998
were: Scurlock, West Texas Intermediate (WTI), $13.00; Louisiana Lt. Sweet Onshore $12.50,
Oklahoma Sweet $13.00; Kern River (13 API) $9.50; Kettleman Hill (34 API)
$12.95; and Wilmington (17 API) $10.10
East Coast Gasoline and Heating Oil
East of the Rockies - Production of gasoline in PADDs I and III was lower
than the previous week. PAD II production increased a small amount. Overall, gasoline stocks
remained about the same in the East.
EIA reported gasoline prices per gallon for Regular on September 14 were as follows: PAD I - $.98, PAD II - $.99,
and PAD III - $0.94.
The price of diesel on September 14: PADDs I - $1.02, PADD II - $1.00, and PADD III -
$.99.
FORECAST: Gasoline prices will follow the price of crude oil, while competition among the
many eastern refiners will keep oil company margins slim.
The price of heating oil should be low through the winter of 1998-99, but the price may inch up
as the price of crude oil increases depending on the amount of competition that occurs between
vendors.
Rocky Mountain Gasoline and Diesel
Rocky Mountain - the price of regular gasoline increased
to $1.11 per gallon and the price of diesel remained at $1.08 per gallon.
Prices should remain stable through September, then may increase with the price of crude oil.
West Coast Gasoline and Diesel Forecast
West Coast - Refiners increased crude oil input to crude stills,
produced less gasoline and more diesel and residual oil. Gasoline inventories dropped from 28.1 to 27.3
million barrels while inventories of diesel increased from 9.1 to 9.9 million barrels. Overall,
the West Coast system remains balanced.
Stocks of residual oil were moved to market, or upgraded bringing inventories back down to normal
levels.
Product prices remain reasonable, although some prices in California increased this week. On September 14, the average price of (reg-mid-premium) gasoline in PAD V was $1.17 per gallon.
The price of Regular in PAD V was $1.13.
The average price of diesel in PAD V increased to $1.10 and Californian's are still paying
$1.16.
FORECAST: The price of gasoline and diesel are expected to mirror increases/decreases in crude
oil in the near term. It remains to be seen whether competition among the western refiners will keep
pricing under control.
Imports
Imports - The 4-week average for gasoline imports decreased from 524 to 460
thousand barrels per day. Distillate imports decreased from a 4 week average of about 180
to 173 thousand bpd, and will remain low due to lack of storage space. Imports of residual oil
decreased from 325 to 291 thousand barrels per day.
©
1998 NOESIS. All rights reserved. Republication and
distribution of the contents of this screen are expressly prohibited without
prior written consent (See note on "Questions" Page)
contact George Clemen at NOESIS
Back to Top
|